Bring back New York soda ban say lawyers
Here’s an interesting piece we came across on Reuters, and wanted to share:
New York City lawyers tried to convince an appeals court on Tuesday to allow Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s ban on large sugary drinks, three months after it was struck down as an illegal overreach of executive power.
The law, invalidated a day before it would have taken effect, barred movie theaters, restaurants and other venues from selling sugary drinks larger than 16 ounces. Convenience stores and grocers would not have been affected.
It was a signature health policy for Bloomberg, who also expanded the city’s ban on indoor smoking.
“Sugary drinks are the highest contributor of sugar in the diet, about 40 percent,” said the city’s lawyer, Fay Ng, arguing the ban was a lawful effort to address an obesity epidemic.
The beverage and restaurant industries challenged the law, and state Supreme Court Justice Milton Tingling in Manhattan struck it down. The judge ruled that the ban’s loopholes made it arbitrary and capricious, and that it was improper for the mayor’s health board to pass it without city council approval.
On Tuesday, the state Supreme Court’s Appellate Division heard arguments in the city’s appeal.
It was not known when the court would rule. Bloomberg will leave office at the end of the year, and it remains an open question whether his successor will seek to impose the ban.
The four judges questioned Ng on the law’s loopholes. Justice Dianne Renwick asked whether it made sense to allow 7-Eleven to sell a 20-ounce soda but not the deli next door. Justice David Friedman raised the specter of possible future rules such as restrictions on donuts.
Ng said the board had based the law on scientific evidence linking the empty calories of sugary drinks with obesity, and there was no reason to believe it would go further.
“The idea that the board of health would run amok…there’s no basis for that,” Ng said.
Richard Bress, a lawyer for plaintiff American Beverage Association, with members including The Coca-Cola Co, PepsiCo Inc and Dr Pepper Snapple Group Inc, said the board should not have bypassed the city council.
“For the first time, an agency was telling people how much of a safe and lawful beverage they could buy,” he said. “When has an administrative agency crossed the line and started making policy for itself?”
Bress acknowledged that the city had provided evidence of a link between sugary drinks and obesity but argued that the ban would do little to address the problem.
Both sides have said the case could have implications for future mayors tackling public health issues such as obesity.
Banning large sugary drinks and sodas can only be a good thing because we all know the dangers of too much sugar in the diet, and more importantly, the dangers of artificial sweeteners such as aspartame with its side effects including depression, brain tumors, migraines and seizures, weight gain and gastro-intestinal problems. Aspartame has been linked to blood cancer – even death.
Have you read our no-holds barred 130-page exposé on the dangers of aspartame? Our special report tells you all you need to know about the killer substance the FDA just won’t ban – despite overwhelming evidence about its dangers. It outlines the reasons why you should cut aspartame out of your diet. Read Aspartame – The Bitter Truth - and we guarantee you will never want to include aspartame products again.
Discover how it is more toxic for men than women, its links to blood cancer, and the shocking story of how it became legal, despite damning research about its toxicity. This is one report you can’t afford to be without.
Featuring everything from where to find aspartame, to the illnesses and side-effects it can cause, the report also includes information from our contributor Dr Betty Martini. You’ll also find a telling timeline including the history of the aspartame controversy, taken from Dr Janet Starr Hull’s book ‘Sweet Poison: How the World’s Most Popular Artificial Sweetener is Killing Us – My Story.’
This report really is a one-stop shop for all things aspartame, highlighting the harmful effects of the sweetener and laying out a number of interesting viewpoints. Care about your health? Are you still giving soda containing aspartame to your kids? Discover why you should ditch the sweetener today.
Visit the store to get your hands on a copy of Aspartame – The Bitter Truth today!
Remember to always consult a licensed healthcare practitioner before embarking on any treatment, it’s your health and it’s IMPORTANT. Disclaimer
If you enjoy reading these articles you might be interested in receiving our monthly newsletter. Read more here
Members don’t forget you can view all past and present Newsletters on the site here